Friday, January 30, 2009

Poker is a game of skill? That explains a lot!

Why do we waste so much time and money prosecuting people for violating ridiculously paternalistic/antiquated/petty laws?

Here is an article discussing whether playing Texas Hold 'em for money (i.e., gambling) violates a state statute forbidding the playing of "any game with cards or dice'' under such circumstances. The statute has been interpreted as only banning games of "chance", but not games of "skill", so the next question that must be answered is whether Texas Hold 'em is a game of chance or a game of skill.

No doubt, many highly paid "experts" will soon waste their time researching and drawing conclusions regarding this truly inane and unanswerable question. More money and time will then be wasted as prosecutors and defense attorneys present their cases to juries, who will then ponder the "evidence" and most likely reach disparate conclusions based almost entirely on mere conjecture.

I have a better idea. Don't allow it to go down that path in the first place. Who really cares whether a few friends do a little gambling at a poker game? Why prosecute it at all. Keep the law in place, so as not to have to pay even more experts to research alternatives and waste the state legislatures' time drafting new provisions, and simply utilize prosecutorial discretion by choosing to not bring these cases. This will even allow certain egregious cases to still be prosecuted, such as a those involving complex gambling/poker rings.

Unfortunately, some prosecutors seem to lack the requisite "skill" needed to perform their jobs with competence.

3 comments:

Joe said...

HAHAHAHA! Holy sh*t. So that means the ENTIRE POPULATION OF NERDS who have swore their soles to playing DUNGEONS AND DRAGONS should be LOCKED UP! Because I'm pretty sure that game involves dice (even those unholy ones of the non-six-sided persuasion) and I'm pretty sure there's absolutely no f-ing skill involved. Skills are things you put on your resume and I've never seen one that says "proficient at wielding the Magical Sword of Slaying and attacking elvish druids in the Evil Forest of Flogforn in which the despicable Enchantress of Solitude brews potions of Eternal Sleep." This would result in a reduction of cases of pimplefication, cantgetadatosis, virginitis, and cramphand in the American teen population.

Verification word is Devermag.

Devermag, vb., ex. I devermag gin her naked.

Rob said...

I have to assume that you missed the part about it only being illegal under "such circumstances," which I previously explained meant gambling...for money. Otherwise, are you telling me that nerds play D&D for MONEY? If that's true, then that's incredible and my entire world-view of the nerd community just changed dramatically. Lock them up!

Joe said...

Ahh yes, missed that part. Sorry, the thought just jumped into my head so quickly I wanted to get it down.

Verification word is hipta.
"Wise up. Don't get hipta yo mama."